|
|
||||||||
2-Containing Inhibitory Glycine Receptors in Embryonic Mouse Hippocampal Neurons
Departments of 1Neurology, 2Pediatrics, and 3Psychiatry and the 4Center for the Study of Nervous System Injury, Washington University School of Medicine; 5Division of Pediatric Neurology and the 6Pediatric Epilepsy Center, St. Louis Children's Hospital, St. Louis, Missouri 63110
Submitted 29 July 2002; accepted in final form 18 March 2003
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-aminobutyric acidA receptors (GABAARs), they may
also modulate GlyRs because binding studies initially suggested that they act
at GlyRs. Furthermore, their diminished ability to potentiate neonatal
GABAARs suggests that they may exert their beneficial clinical
effects at another site in the developing brain. Therefore we examined the
effect of benzodiazepines on whole cell currents mediated by GlyRs in cultured
embryonic mouse hippocampal neurons. First, we determined the GlyR subunit
composition in this preparation. Glycine,
-alanine, and taurine activate
strychnine-sensitive chloride currents in a dose-dependent manner. Maximal
concentrations of the three agonists produce equal, nonadditive responses as
expected of full agonists. The pharmacological properties of the GlyR currents
including their pattern of modulation by picrotoxinin, picrotin, and
tropisetron indicate that GlyRs consist of
2
heteromers and
2 homomers. Reverse transcriptase polymerase
chain reaction (RTPCR) studies confirmed the presence of
2
and
subunits. Second, we found that micromolar concentrations of some
benzodiazepines, including chlordiazepoxide and nitrazepam, inhibit GlyR
currents. Nitrazepam inhibition of GlyRs is noncompetitive, is not voltage
dependent, and does not reflect enhanced desensitization. Thus benzodiazepines
allosterically inhibit
2-containing GlyRs in embryonic mouse
hippocampal neurons via a "low"-affinity site. | INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
and two
subunits (reviewed in
Legendre 2001
subunit has four isoforms (
14) while the
subunit only has one. Although
subunit isoforms show both
developmental and regional variation, the CNS expresses GlyRs diffusely
throughout life. Along with
-aminobutyric acidA receptors
(GABAARs), they mediate fast inhibitory synaptic transmission in
the brain stem and spinal cord. While their function in the cortex remains
unclear, they may have a role in cortical development
(Flint et al. 1998
Various agents positively and/or negatively modulate GlyRs. For example,
ethanol (Ye et al.
2001a
,b
),
steroids (Maksay et al. 2001
),
dihydropyridines (Chesnoy-Marchais and
Cathala 2001
), tropeines
(Supplisson and Chesnoy-Marchais
2000
), and zinc (Chattipakorn
and McMahon 2002
; Laube et al.
1995
) modulate GlyRs positively and negatively. The type of
modulation exerted can depend on the subunit composition as with
GABAARs. Indeed, many modulators of GABAARs are also
modulators of GlyRs as might be expected from the homology between these
receptors, which both belong to the cysteine loop superfamily of ligand-gated
ion channels (Karlin and Akabas
1995
).
Benzodiazepines are a clinically important class of GABAARs
potentiators frequently used to treat a variety of neuropsychiatric disorders
including anxiety, spasticity, and seizures in patients of all ages. Although
benzodiazepines were initially hypothesized to exert their clinical effects
through GlyRs because they displace strychnine in binding assays
(Young et al. 1974
but see
Hunt and Raynaud 1977
),
subsequent electrophysiological studies demonstrated no effect of
benzodiazepines on GlyRs (Choi et al.
1981
; Macdonald and Barker
1978
). However, this discrepancy between the binding and the
electrophysiological studies with respect to GlyRs remains unresolved. In
addition, benzodiazepine potentiation of GABAARs in the neonatal
brain is much less pronounced than in the adult
(Brooks-Kayal et al. 2001
;
Rovira and Ben Ari 1993
;
Zhang et al. 1993
). This
observation raises the possibility that other receptors, such as GlyRs, may
mediate the effects of benzodiazepines in the neonate. Therefore we tested the
hypothesis that benzodiazepines modulate GlyRs.
We examined the effect of benzodiazepines on GlyRs in cultured embryonic
mouse hippocampal neurons using whole cell patch-clamp recordings. First, we
demonstrated that cultured mouse embryonic hippocampal neurons express
2
heteromeric and
2 homomeric GlyRs
using pharmacological and reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction
(RT-PCR) techniques. We found that several benzodiazepines inhibit
2-containing GlyRs and that nitrazepam acts
noncompetitively.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Timed pregnant Swiss Webster mice (Taconic Farms, Germantown, NY) at day 16 of gestation were anesthetized with 5% halothane and killed by cervical dislocation. Embryos were removed by cesarean section and decapitated. The brains of five embryos were removed. The hippocampi were dissected and sliced in Leibovitz's L-15 media (Gibco BRL, Grand Island, NY) containing 0.4 mg/ml bovine serum albumin before being enzymatically digested at 37°C for 20 min in the same solution to which 1 mg/ml papain was added. Then the slices were gently triturated with a glass pipette in plating media containing 1x minimum essential medium with Earle's salts (Gibco BRL), 10% Nu-Serum (Collaborative Biomedical Products, Bedford, MA), 5 mg/ml glucose, 2.2 mg/ml NaHCO3, 20 units/ml penicillin, and 20 µg/ml streptomycin. The resulting single cell suspension was centrifuged for 5 min at 1,000 rpm in the presence of 0.25 mg/ml BSA and 0.25 mg/ml trypsin inhibitor. The pellet was resuspended in plating media and then plated on a monolayer of passaged cortical astrocytes at a density of 2.5 x 105 cells/ml. To inhibit glial proliferation, 5-fluoro-2'-deoxyuridine and uridine were added to a final concentration of 15 and 35 µg/ml, respectively, at 48 h. Recordings were made from neurons incubated for 414 days.
Whole cell patch-clamp electrophysiology
Voltage-clamp recordings from embryonic mouse hippocampal neurons were made
using an Axopatch 200A amplifier (Axon Instruments, Union City, CA) in the
whole cell patch-clamp mode. All experiments were performed at a holding
potential of 65 mV unless otherwise indicated. All holding potentials
were corrected for junction potentials, which were measured empirically for
each pipette solution (Neher
1992
). Ramp current-voltage relationships were obtained by
subjecting neurons to a voltage ramp of 0.1 V/s. Series resistance
compensation was set at 9095%, and the 4-pole low-pass filter on the
amplifier was set at 15 kHz.
Neurons were bathed in an extracellular solution containing (in mM) 140
NaCl, 5 KCl, 1.5 CaCl2, 1 MgCl2, 10
D-glucose, 2.5 x 104
tetrodotoxin, and 10
N-[2-hydroxyethyl]piperazine-N'-[2-ethanesulfonic
acid] (HEPES) (pH 7.357.38). Patch pipettes had resistances of
24 M
after fire-polishing when filled with a solution containing
(in mM) 140 CsCl, 4 NaCl, 0.5 CaCl2, 5 ethylene
glycol-bis(2-aminoethylether)-N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic
acid (EGTA), and 10 HEPES (pH 7.36). In some experiments, the pipette solution
contained 140 mM Cs methanesulfonate (CsCH3SO3) or 70 mM
CsCl + 70 mM CsCH3SO3 rather than 140 mM CsCl. Solutions
had osmolarities of 283293 mosM.
The bath was continuously perfused with extracellular solution at 0.5
ml/min. The bath temperature was monitored continuously with a thermister and
ranged from 22 to 24°C. In addition, the neuron being studied was
continuously perfused with either extracellular solution or a test solution at
2 ml/min using a multibarrel, gravity-driven, flowtube system developed for
studying rapidly desensitizing glutamate currents. Drugs were dissolved in the
extracellular solution and applied with this system. Drugs, which were not
water soluble, were first dissolved in dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) before being
added to the extracellular solution. When DMSO was used, the same DMSO
concentration was present in all solutions. The highest final concentration of
DMSO used was 0.1% except for those experiments using chlordiazepoxide
concentrations >500 µM in which the final DMSO concentration was 2%. In
the presence of 0.1% DMSO, 50 µM glycine currents were 94 ± 4% (mean
± SE, n = 4) of control. Chlordiazepoxide concentrations
>500 µM were obtained by diluting a 100 mM stock solution made with 100%
DMSO. The experiments were performed before the chlordiazepoxide precipitated
out of solution, which occurred
30 min after it was prepared. In the
presence of 2% DMSO, 50 µM glycine currents were 89 ± 7% (n
= 3) of control.
Data analysis
Whole cell currents were digitized at 510 kHz using pCLAMP 8 (Axon
Instruments) and were analyzed using pCLAMP 8, Origin 6 and 7 (OriginLab,
Northampton, MA), and Microsoft Excel 2000 (Microsoft, Redmond, WA).
Applications of agonist in the absence and presence of a modulator were
interleaved. Experimental peak currents were compared with the average of the
bracketing control peak currents. Control currents generally changed by
<10%. Typically, two to three trials from each neuron were included in the
analysis. Exponential processes were fit to the function
I(t)
![]() | (1) |
j,
and C is a constant. Exponential fits to desensitizing currents
started at the point the peak current had decayed by 5%. k was
determined using an F test and by visual inspection of the residual
plots. The weighted mean time constant,
mean, was calculated
by
![]() | (2) |
![]() | (3) |
Agonist dose-response curves were fit to the logistic equation
![]() | (4) |
![]() | (5) |
Data from the fits are presented as mean ± SE along with 95% confidence intervals when necessary, whereas all other data are presented as mean ± SE with n being the number of cells examined. Means from two samples were compared using a t-test while means from three or more samples were compared using a one-way ANOVA. Statistical significance was set at P < 0.05.
RT-PCR
Previously published methods (Heck et
al. 1997
) were adapted as follows for RT-PCR detection of GlyR
subunit and gephyrin mRNA. RNA from embryonic mouse hippocampal neurons
cultured for 7 days and adult (60-day-old) mouse brain was harvested and
quantified spectrophotometrically. Equal quantities of hippocampal culture RNA
and whole brain RNA were converted to cDNA in single reactions. Then the cDNA
was aliquotted for each specific PCR reaction. Individual primer pairs
designated P1 and P2 by Heck et al.
(1997
) specific for GlyR
1,
2,
3, or
subunits or gephyrin were used. First-strand synthesis was primed with
oligo-dT. PCR was performed at an annealing temperature of 56°C and
amplified with a modified Taq polymerase (Expand, Roche Applied
Science, Indianapolis, IN) according to the manufacturer's protocol. Products
were electrophoretically separated on a 1.5% agarose gel and stained with
ethidium bromide.
Materials
Flumazenil was a gift from F. Hoffman-La Roche (Basel, Switzerland), RO 15-4513 was a gift from Charles F. Zorumski (Washington University, St. Louis, MO), and GYKI 52466 was a gift from Istvan Tarnawa (IVAX Drug Research Institute, Budapest, Hungary). All other chemicals were obtained from Sigma (St. Louis, MO) unless stated otherwise.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We classified the responses of cultured embryonic mouse hippocampal neurons into three categories. Of 268 neurons exposed to saturating (1001,000 µM, see following text) glycine concentrations, 246 (92%) showed a slowly desensitizing current (Fig. 1A), whereas 20 (7%) showed no detectable response, 2 (<1%) showed only a rapidly desensitizing response (Fig. 1B), and 2 (<1%) showed both a slowly and rapidly desensitizing response. Because two neurons showed a rapidly desensitizing current with subsaturating glycine concentrations, a total of six or <1% of all neurons (6/937) examined in this study showed a rapidly desensitizing current.
|
The slowly desensitizing current elicited by a 20-s application of 300
µM glycine decayed to 92 ± 1% (n = 12) of its peak along a
two-exponential time course in 92% (11/12) of neurons. The faster time
constant was 1.0 ± 0.9 s (3401,800 ms, n = 11) and the
slower time constant was 5.0 ± 0.5s (2.69.1s, n = 12)
with the faster time constant accounting for 48 ± 8% (1478%,
n = 11) of the desensitization
(Fig. 1A1). We have
not identified the reason for the variability in the desensitization
parameters, but it may reflect the variability in GlyR density
(Legendre et al. 2002
) or
phosphorylation (Gentet and Clements
2002
), two factors that modulate GlyR desensitization. Recovery
followed a two-exponential time course with a weighted mean time constant of
11s (Fig. 1A2 and
1A3). Both the rate and degree of desensitization
depended on glycine concentration. With 10 µM glycine, the current decayed
to 75 ± 3% (n = 6) of its peak along a single exponential in
83% (5/6) neurons with a weighted mean time constant of 14.9 ± 2.8 s
(n = 6). Thus glycine currents in >90% of the neurons studied
desensitized with kinetics similar to those in other neurons
(Akaike and Kaneda 1989
;
Fatima-Shad and Barry 1995
;
Krishtal et al. 1988
;
Melnick and Baev 1993
) and to
the slower components of desensitization in outside-out patches from brain
stem neurons (Harty and Manis
1998
; Legendre
1998
).
The rapidly desensitizing current elicited by 20100 µM glycine
decayed to 83 ± 7% (n = 6) of its peak along a
single-exponential time course (Fig.
1B). When elicited by 100 µM glycine, the time
constant was 39 ± 5 ms (n = 4), which is similar to the faster
components of desensitization in outside-out patches
(Harty and Manis 1998
;
Legendre 1998
). The rapidly
desensitizing current did not recover. We did not study the rapidly
desensitizing current further because it was rare and did not recover under
the conditions used in this study. The results presented in the following text
apply only to the slowly desensitizing current. Specifically, subsequent
references to fast and slow components of desensitization refer only to the
slowly desensitizing current.
Glycine,
-alanine, and taurine are full agonists of a
strychnine-sensitive chloride conductance
Glycine,
-alanine, and taurine evoked dose-dependent currents
(Fig. 2A).
Table 1 shows the
EC50 and Hill coefficient for each agonist, which are similar to
previous reports using dissociated neurons
(Krishtal et al. 1988
;
Lewis et al. 1991
;
McCool and Botting 2000
).
Because we derived the dose-response curve for each agonist by normalizing
peak currents to the peak current elicited by 100 µM glycine, we can
directly compare the maximum responses. All three agonists evoked comparable
maximal responses with the order of potency being glycine >
-alanine
> taurine (Fig.
2A2). Prior studies using both native neurons and
expression systems reported the same order of potency
(Harvey et al. 2000
;
Krishtal et al. 1988
;
Lewis et al. 1991
;
McCool and Botting 2000
;
Schmieden et al. 1992
,
1999
).
|
|
To prove that these agonists activate a Cl conductance,
we obtained current-voltage plots (Fig.
2B1) for each agonist using three different internal
[Cl]. When the internal and external [Cl]
were near 140 mM, the current-voltage plots were nearly linear as confirmed by
the ratio of the chord conductance at +55 mV to that at 65 mV being
near one for each agonist (Table
1). Semi-logarithmic plots showed that the reversal potentials for
each agonist vary linearly with the logarithm of the internal
[Cl] with slopes near 50 mV
(Fig. 2B2,
Table 1). These values are less
than the expected value of 58.6 mV for a chloride selective conductance.
Because the deviation occurs primarily at low internal [Cl],
one explanation for this difference may be intracellular Cl
accumulation by the K+-Cl cotransporter at low
internal [Cl] (DeFazio
et al. 2000
). Theoretically,
CH3SO3 permeation through the GlyR
channel may also contribute.
Strychnine and bicuculline are the antagonists often used to define GlyRs
and GABAARs, respectively. Strychnine reversibly inhibited the
current elicited by an EC50 concentration of each agonist with a
low nanomolar IC50 when strychnine was preapplied
(Fig. 2C,
Table 1). Strychnine was more
potent when preapplied as previously reported
(McCool and Botting 2000
).
Bicuculline also reversibly inhibited the current elicited by an
EC50 concentration of each agonist with a low micromolar or greater
IC50 (Fig.
2D, Table
1). It was significantly more potent against glycine than
-alanine and taurine currents (Table
1). GlyRs in other preparations have a similar pharmacological
profile (Harvey et al. 2000
;
Jonas et al. 1998
;
Krishtal et al. 1988
;
Lewis et al. 1991
;
McCool and Botting 2000
;
O'Brien and Berger 1999
;
Schmieden et al. 1992
,
1999
;
Shirasaki et al. 1991
), which
is distinct from GABAARs (Table
1).
The preceding results suggest that glycine,
-alanine, and taurine are
full agonists at GlyRs. To provide further evidence for this hypothesis, we
compared peak currents elicited by saturating concentrations of each agonist
alone to those elicited by a saturating concentration of glycine +
-alanine and glycine + taurine. Saturating concentrations of
-alanine, taurine, glycine +
-alanine, and glycine + taurine
produced responses equal to glycine alone
(Fig. 2E). Taken
together, these data demonstrate that glycine,
-alanine, and taurine are
full agonists at GlyRs in cultured embryonic mouse hippocampal neurons.
Cultured embryonic mouse hippocampal neurons express
2-containing GlyRs
In situ hybridization studies indicate that both
2 and
subunits are expressed in the embryonic hippocampus with
3 being expressed postnatally
(Malosio et al. 1991
).
1 is not expressed in the hippocampus at any age.
4 is not expressed in the brain at high levels
(Harvey et al. 2000
;
Matzenbach et al. 1994
). Three
variants of
2 exist:
2A,
2B, and
(Kuhse et al.
1990
,
1991
).
2A
and
2B are formed by alternative splicing.
differs from
2A by
one amino acid, and the two may be allelic variations of the same gene. In the
hippocampus,
2B transcripts decline postnatally while
2A transcripts persist.
is only expressed in neonates. Thus we
expected to find
2 and
subunits in our preparation.
The next series of experiments tested this hypothesis.
GlyR subunits when expressed alone or in 
pairs form
functional channels. Although the pharmacological profile of the glycine
current does not correlate with a unique subunit composition, it eliminates
some possibilities. We will begin by considering the results already
presented. First, strychnine is not a potent inhibitor of
and
homomers
(Grenningloh et al. 1990
;
Kuhse et al. 1990
). Second,
strychnine is not a potent inhibitor of
2 homomers when
activated by taurine (Schmieden et al.
1992
). Third,
homomers require 100-fold higher agonist
concentrations for activation than
subunit containing GlyRs
(Grenningloh et al. 1990
). In
contrast, we found that strychnine is a potent antagonist of GlyR currents
regardless of the agonist used. In addition, the EC50 for each
agonist is comparable or lower than that obtained in other preparations known
or thought to contain
subunits
(Harvey et al. 2000
;
Jonas et al. 1998
;
Krishtal et al. 1988
;
Lewis et al. 1991
;
McCool and Botting 2000
;
Schmieden et al. 1992
,
1999
). These results suggest
that the majority of the GlyRs in our preparation are not
2,
, or
homomers.
We examined the effect of picrotoxinin to better define the subunit
composition (Fig. 3).
Picrotoxinin blocks
1,
2, and
3 homomers with an IC50 of 59 µM, both
1
and
3
heteromers with an
IC50 over 1 mM, and
2
heteromers with an
IC50 of 20 or 300 µM using glycine concentrations at or above
the EC50 (Bloomenthal et al.
1994
; McCool and Farroni
2001
; Pribilla et al.
1992
). In our neurons, picrotoxinin reversibly inhibited glycine
currents with an IC50 that depended on glycine concentration as
shown previously (Lynch et al.
1995
; Yoon et al.
1998
) (Fig.
3A). Picrotoxinin inhibited 20 µM (EC20),
50 µM (EC50), and 300 µM (EC100, see
Fig. 2A2 and
Table 1) glycine currents with
a corresponding IC50 and Hill coefficient of 21 ± 5 µM
and 0.9 ± 0.1, 82 ± 13 µM and 0.9 ± 0.1, and 190
± 40 µM and 0.7 ± 0.1, respectively. Notably, picrotoxinin
does not block 20 µM glycine currents with an IC50 <10 µM.
In addition, the picrotoxinin inhibition curves are not obviously biphasic.
Yoon et al. (1998
) obtained
biphasic curves that they attributed to the presence of two types of GlyRs
each having a different subunit composition and EC50 for activation
by glycine. However, a biphasic curve would not be seen if the two receptor
types have a similar EC50. Nevertheless, this intermediate
sensitivity to picrotoxinin suggests the presence of both
2
heteromers and
2 homomers
(Chattipakorn and McMahon
2002
).
|
To provide further evidence for the presence of
subunits, we
examined the effect of picrotin and tropisetron. Picrotin (100 µM) reduces
1 and
3 homomer-mediated responses by 90%,
whereas it reduces
1
and
3
heteromer mediated responses by ≤25%
(Steinbach et al. 2000
).
2 subunits were not examined in this study. We found that
picrotin reversibly inhibited 50 µM glycine currents with an
IC50 of 330 ± 190 µM and a Hill coefficient of 0.6
± 0.2 (Fig.
3B). The relatively weak inhibition by picrotin suggests
that
subunits exist in our neurons. Tropisetron, a tropeine,
biphasically modulates
1 homomers,
1
heteromers, and
2
heteromers while it only inhibits
2 homomers (Supplisson
and Chesnoy-Marchais 2000
). Tropisetron concentrations <1 µM
augmented, whereas those >10 µM inhibited 20 µM glycine
(EC20, see Fig.
2A2) currents (Fig.
3C). We used an EC20 concentration to
facilitate observing both potentiation and block. This finding suggests that
2 homomers do not predominate.
Therefore the pharmacological profile indicates that embryonic hippocampal
neurons contain both
2 and
subunits. While both
2
heteromers and
2 homomers exist,
our results also indicate that GlyRs in these neurons are primarily
2
heteromers. The presence of
4
cannot be excluded (Harvey et al.
2000
).
Although the pharmacological profile of glycine currents has correctly
identified the GlyR subunit composition in other preparations
(McCool and Farroni 2001
), the
conclusion that cultured embryonic mouse hippocampal neurons express
2-containing GlyRs assumes that native and expressed GlyRs
have the same pharmacological properties. To confirm the presence of
2 and
subunits in our cultures, we turned to RT-PCR
(Heck et al. 1997
). Our
cultures expressed mRNA transcripts for
2 subunits,
subunits, and gephyrin but not
1 and
3
subunits (Fig. 4). As expected,
the adult mouse brain expressed
1,
2,
3, and
subunit as well as gephyrin mRNA.
|
Some benzodiazepines inhibit glycine currents
We screened several benzodiazepines for their effect on 50 µM glycine
(EC50, see Fig.
2A2 and Table
1) currents. At 20200 µM, the 1,4-benzodiazepines,
chlordiazepoxide, nitrazepam, and lorazepam; the 1,4-benzodiazepines with a
fused triazolo ring, alprazolam and triazolam; the competitive benzodiazepine
antagonist, flumazenil; and the partial inverse benzodiazepine agonist, RO
154513, inhibited 50 µM glycine currents by ≥20%. For example,
chlordiazepoxide inhibited 50 µM glycine currents in a dose-dependent
manner with an IC50 of 230 ± 38 µM and a Hill coefficient
of 0.8 ± 0.1 (Fig. 5).
Young et al. (1974
) found that
chlordiazepoxide blocked strychnine binding to rat brainstem and spinal cord
synaptic membranes with an identical potency. In contrast, 100 µM diazepam
(a 1,4-benzodiazepine), 100 µM clobazam (a 1,5-benzodiazepine), and 30
µM GYKI 52466 (a 2,3-benzodiazepine) inhibited 50 µM glycine currents by
<20%.
|
We examined nitrazepam in detail because it was one of the more potent
benzodiazepines tested, and it did not precipitate out of an aqueous solution
at higher concentrations. Nitrazepam inhibited 50 µM glycine responses with
an IC50 of 83 ± 14 µM and a Hill coefficient of 1.3
± 0.2 (Fig. 6, A and
B). Nitrazepam blocks strychnine binding to rat brain
stem and spinal cord synaptic membranes with a similar potency
(Hunt and Raynaud 1977
;
Young et al. 1974
). Because
some dihydropyridines such as nitrendipine and nicardipine block responses to
high glycine concentrations and potentiate responses to low glycine
concentrations (Chesnoy-Marchais and
Cathala 2001
), we examined the effect of nitrazepam on 20 µM
(EC20) and 200 µM (EC100, see
Fig. 2A2) glycine
currents. Unlike nitrendipine and nicardipine, nitrazepam inhibited both 20
and 200 µM glycine currents (Fig.
6B). Chlordiazepoxide also inhibited 20 µM glycine
currents (data not shown). The similarity of the dose-response curves for
nitrazepam inhibition of 20, 50, and 200 µM glycine currents suggests that
the inhibition is noncompetitive. Further support for noncompetitive
inhibition comes from the rightward shift and decreased maximum in the glycine
dose-response curve when nitrazepam is present
(Fig. 6C). In the
presence of 80 µM nitrazepam, glycine had an EC50 of 120
± 23 µM and a Hill coefficient of 1.4 ± 0.1 with a 22%
decrease in the maximum current. Nitrazepam block was not voltage-dependent
because the degree of block at 65 and +35 mV was the same
(Fig. 6D). Finally,
nitrazepam did alter the reversal potential of glycine currents. Using
symmetric [Cl] solutions, 50 µM glycine currents reversed
at 1.8 ± 0.8 mV (n = 4) and 3.0 ± 0.9 mV (n =
4) in the absence and presence of 100 µM nitrazepam as determined by
subjecting steady-state currents to voltage ramps.
|
Nitrazepam may inhibit GlyRs by enhancing desensitization. Indeed,
chlordiazepoxide enhances GABAAR desensitization
(Mierlak and Farb 1988
). In
the presence of 100 µM nitrazepam, 300 µM glycine currents had peak
amplitudes that were 56 ± 4% (n = 8) of control and
desensitized along a two-exponential time course as control currents did.
While nitrazepam increased the fast time constant by 50%, it did not alter the
slow time constant, the relative contributions of each time constant, or the
weighted mean time constant (Fig. 7,
AC). The time course of recovery from
desensitization for 300 µM glycine currents followed a single exponential
with a time constant of 7.6 ± 1.1s in the presence of 100 µM
nitrazepam (Fig. 7D).
Nitrazepam may accelerate recovery from desensitization slightly given a
weighted mean time constant of 11 s in the absence of nitrazepam. Similarly,
50 µM nitrazepam did not alter the desensitization parameters for 10 µM
glycine currents (data not shown). Thus nitrazepam did not enhance GlyR
desensitization.
|
We preapplied the benzodiazepines for 30 s before coapplying with glycine because greater inhibition occurred with preapplication. In addition, the inhibition required the presence of the benzodiazepine during the glycine application. For example, the peak amplitude of 50 µM glycine currents was 14 ± 6% (n = 6) of control when 100 µM nitrazepam was both preand co-applied with glycine. Peak 50 µM glycine currents were 33 ± 10% (n = 6) of control when 100 µM nitrazepam was co-applied but not preapplied. When 100 µM nitrazepam was preapplied but not co-applied with glycine, 50 µM glycine currents were 82 ± 2 (n = 4) of control. Similar results were obtained with alprazolam.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2-containing GlyRs in cultured embryonic mouse hippocampal
neurons. This study provides electrophysiological evidence for an inhibitory
benzodiazepine site on GlyRs. Although Young et al.
(1974
Cultured embryonic mouse hippocampal neurons express
2-containing GlyRs
GlyR subunit composition changes during development in the spinal cord,
which expresses
2 homomers prenatally and
1
heteromers in the adult
(Rajendra et al. 1997
).
Location is a second factor influencing GlyR subunit composition based on in
situ hybridization results (Malosio et al.
1991
). For example, the embryonic hippocampus expresses both
2 and
GlyR subunits, which our RT-PCR results
confirm. However, in situ hybridization cannot determine whether GlyRs are
2
heteromers or
2 and
homomers. The pharmacological properties of these subunit combinations can
help determine which ones exist (see RESULTS). Because the
pharmacological properties of GlyRs in embryonic hippocampal neurons have not
been reported, this was one goal of our study. The pharmacological properties
indicate that the GlyRs are primarily
2
heteromers but
2 homomers also exist. We cannot exclude the presence of low
levels of other subunit combinations such as
3
, which
may account for the rare rapidly desensitizing current. Alternatively, the
rapidly desensitizing current may depend on second-messenger modulation
(Gentet and Clements 2002
).
2
heteromers may persist into adulthood because the
juvenile hippocampus (Chattipakorn and
McMahon 2002
) and adult amygdala
(McCool and Farroni 2001
)
express the same subunit combination. Furthermore, in situ hybridization fails
to detect
1 expression in the adult hippocampus
(Malosio et al. 1991
). Thus
GlyR subunit composition depends on both location and age, and the effect of
GlyR modulators will vary with location and age.
Although
-alanine's role in the CNS remains unknown, taurine plays an
important role during brain development
(Palackal et al. 1986
).
Because
-alanine and taurine activate both GlyRs and GABAARs
(Choquet and Korn 1988
;
del Olmo et al. 2000
), the
receptor mediating their actions in different regions of the CNS during
development is unclear. Glycine, taurine, and
-alanine currents have
similar pharmacological and physiological profiles in embryonic hippocampal
neurons. Indeed, based on their interaction with glycine at saturating
concentrations, they appear to activate GlyRs exclusively at the
concentrations tested. Thus GlyRs, which may be the primary receptor for
taurine in the developing neocortex (Flint
et al. 1998
) and postnatal hippocampus
(Mori et al. 2002
), may also
be the primary receptor for taurine and
-alanine in the embryonic
hippocampus. The difference in the sensitivity of glycine currents to
bicuculline compared with
-alanine and taurine currents may reflect a
difference in the binding site and/or gating mechanism for these agonists
(Han et al. 2001
;
Schmieden et al. 1992
).
Taurine activates GlyRs as either a full or a partial agonist depending on
the preparation. Taurine may be a partial agonist in some cases because it
acts as an antagonist via a specific domain in the
1 subunit
(Schmieden et al. 1999
).
However, other factors may be involved because taurine ranges from a full
agonist to a partial agonist as the glycine EC50 increases for
1 and
2 homomers expressed in oocytes
(de Saint et al. 2001
). We
found that taurine is a full agonist on
2-containing GlyRs
in embryonic hippocampal neurons. In contrast, it is a partial agonist in
adult amygdala neurons (McCool and Botting
2000
), which express the same subunit combination
(McCool and Farroni 2001
).
Together, these results indicate that factors in addition to subunit
composition determine whether taurine acts as a full or partial agonist.
Benzodiazepine inhibition of GlyRs
Benzodiazepine concentrations similar to those that block
2-containing GlyRs modulate GABAARs and inhibit
some voltage-gated ion channels. GABAARs have both a
"high-" and "low-"affinity benzodiazepine site
(Walters et al. 2000
).
Diazepam at 20100 µM potentiates
1
2
2 GABAARs
via a low-affinity site. Interestingly, these same concentrations acting at
the high-affinity site inhibit
1
2
2 GABAARs
(Rovira and Ben Ari 1993
;
Walters et al. 2000
). Walters
et al. (2000
) postulate that
the low-affinity site mediates the anesthetic effects of benzodiazepines. We
hypothesize that GlyRs have a low-affinity benzodiazepine site homologous to
the low-affinity benzodiazepine site on GABAARs because both
receptors belong to the same family. Benzodiazepines at 10200 µM
also inhibit neuronal voltage-gated sodium, low- and high-threshold calcium,
and delayed rectifier potassium channels
(Backus et al. 1991
;
Yang et al. 1987
). The
presence of a low-affinity benzodiazepine site on both ligand- and
voltage-gated channels suggests that the site influences channel gating rather
than ligand binding or the voltage sensor. This lowaffinity benzodiazepine
site may be analogous to the conserved inhibitory pentobarbital site on
various ligand- and voltage-gated channels hypothesized by Akk and Steinbach
(2000
). Furthermore, our
findings indicate that GlyRs lack a high-affinity, potentiating benzodiazepine
site.
Nitrazepam does not inhibit
2-containing GlyRs by a
simple open channel block mechanism or by promoting desensitization. The lack
of greater inhibition with higher agonist concentrations excludes a simple
open channel block mechanism. Nitrazepam does not alter the slow time constant
of desensitization, the weighted mean time constant of desensitization, or the
degree of desensitization, but it significantly prolongs the faster time
constant of desensitization. It also may slightly accelerate recovery from
desensitization overall despite eliminating the faster component of recovery.
The net effect of slowing the entry of GlyRs into the desensitized state and
increasing the rate of recovery from desensitization would not result in
smaller currents. Thus these effects on desensitization do not account for its
inhibition of GlyR currents, and we conclude that nitrazepam does not block
GlyR currents by enhancing desensitization.
Nitrazepam inhibition is noncompetitive because it shifts the glycine
dose-response curve to the right and diminishes the maximum response. A
noncompetitive inhibitor should allow glycine to occupy all binding sites at
saturating concentrations. Therefore nitrazepam inhibits GlyRs by altering
channel gating and/or other transitions between ligand bound channel states
through an allosteric mechanism (Colquhoun
1998
). However, we cannot exclude the possibility that nitrazepam
also alters glycine binding allosterically.
Clinical relevance
The low-affinity benzodiazepine site on GlyRs and GABAARs may
have several important clinical roles. First, Rigo et al.
(2002
) recently demonstrated
that levetiracetam, a novel antiepileptic drug, may modulate GlyRs and
GABAARs to a lesser extent via a low-affinity benzodiazepine site.
Second, the low-affinity site on the GlyR may mediate some of the effects of
anesthetic doses of benzodiazepines, the hypothesized role for the site on
GABAARs (Walters et al.
2000
). As expected from our results, mice with diminished GlyR
function are more sensitive to the anesthetic effects of midazolam
(Quinlan et al. 2002
). Third,
GlyR inhibition via this site may be one mechanism by which benzodiazepines
stop neonatal seizures because GlyR activation produces a depolarizing rather
than a hyperpolarizing response in neonatal neurons
(Ito and Cherubini 1991
). Thus
the relative inability of benzodiazepines to augment neonatal
GABAARs may be advantageous clinically. While the benzodiazepine
concentrations needed to inhibit GlyRs are higher that those needed to augment
GABAARs, the cerebrospinal fluid concentrations achieved clinically
in neonates are unknown. Finally, this site may mediate the effects of the
high dose benzodiazepine regimens used to treat electrical status epilepticus
during slow wave sleep (De Negri et al.
1995
) and nonketotic hyperglycinemia, a condition associated with
elevated cerebrospinal fluid glycine concentrations and severe neonatal
seizures (Matalon et al.
1983
).
In summary, benzodiazepines inhibit
2-containing GlyRs in
embryonic mouse hippocampal neurons via a low-affinity benzodiazepine site
that may have several important roles clinically.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This work was supported by National Institutes of Neurological Disorders and Stroke Grants 5K12NS-0169004 and 1K02NS-43278-01.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Address for reprint requests: Correspondence: Liu Lin Thio, M.D., Ph.D., Pediatric Epilepsy Center, Suite 12E47, St. Louis Children's Hospital, One Children's Place, St. Louis, MO 63110 (E-mail: thio{at}kids.wustl.edu).
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Akk G and Steinbach JH. Activation and block of recombinant GABAA receptors by pentobarbitone: a single-channel study. Br J Pharmacol 130: 249258, 2000.[ISI]
Backus KH, Pflimlin P, and Trube G. Action of diazepam on the voltage-dependent Na+ current. Comparison with the effects of phenytoin, carbamazepine, lidocaine and flumazenil. Brain Res 548: 4149, 1991.[ISI][Medline]
Becker CM, Betz H, and Schröder H. Expression of inhibitory glycine receptors in postnatal rat cerebral cortex. Brain Res 606: 220226, 1993.[ISI][Medline]
Bloomenthal AB, Goldwater E, Pritchett DB, and Harrison NL. Biphasic modulation of the strychnine-sensitive glycine receptor by Zn2+. Mol Pharmacol 46: 11561159, 1994.[Abstract]
Brooks-Kayal AR, Shumate MD, Jin H, Rikhter TY, Kelly ME, and
Coulter DA.
-Aminobutyric acidA receptor subunit
expression predicts functional changes in hippocampal dentate granule cells
during postnatal development. J Neurochem
77: 12661278,
2001.[ISI][Medline]
Chattipakorn SC and McMahon LL. Pharmacological characterization of glycine-gated chloride
currents recorded in rat hippocampal slices. J
Neurophysiol 87:
15151525, 2002.